Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Genesis 19.0-29.0

19

The Depravity of Sodom

Enough said about that. Lot’s courage in offering his daughters, oh that my own father could be so righteous? Well, I suppose he was doing the best he could with what he knew. This seems to come up again and again, I wonder if it is a purposeful lesson or simply an idea of how much times have changed: what once seemed acceptable, if regrettable, is no longer even allowed in bar-jokes. Or is it?

Sodom and Gomorrah Destroyed

“But Lot’s wife, behind him, looked back, and she became a pillar of salt.” The beginning of a Vonnegut book and, according to the footnotes, an explanation of an actual strange geological formation in the Dead Sea area. What an interesting scene. More than any passages I have read so far, this one seems very full of small meanings and great lessons. Lot’s being singled out as a innocent man, even in his slightly wicked ways; his inability to get his son-in-laws out of the city; his wife’s very human desire to look back, all are somehow moving. The scene is a mix between a riveting story of survival and a moral tale. Also, this is the J version, which up to date seems just a bit more wickedly imaginative…

The Shameful Origin of Moab and Ammon

Moabites and Ammonites. This episode, somewhat out of place, sounds like a dirty way to bash on your frenemies. “Yeah, don’t worry Mr. Moabite and Mrs. Ammonite, we mentioned you in the bible.” (snigger snigger) I guess we will see how the next mention of these two groups goes.

20

Abraham and Sarah at Gerar

Back to Gerar, but now told in the E source. “You have done things to me that not ought to be done.” When will we learn just what these things are, and why on earth is this a learned trait? Is it not something we should all be born with? Maybe we will learn, either later in the bible, or at the ‘end of the world as we know it.’ This brings to mind: how boring and short a book the bible might have been if only we knew better than to eat the fruit.

21

The Birth of Isaac

E, J and P sources all. Isaac means laughter, as Sarah laughs at her age in childbearing.

Hagar and Ishmael Sent Away

Ok. So third time, roughly of this story, this time the E version. Ishmael is a young boy, Hagar and Abraham’s son. They are sent away for “Isaac-ing” on the day of Isaac’s birth, but the Lord promises Abraham, this time ‘very distressed,’ that Ishmael too will be in some way more than ok. He is to become the father of Arabs. Is this all right? Very confusing to remember, so perhaps the repetition really is beneficial, if confusing.

Abraham and Abimelech Make a Covenant

E again. “And Abraham resided as an alien many days in the land of the Philistines.” So, he really is an alien, although the conflict is not as great as what it will become. He plants a tamarisk to signify the pact, and the pact signifies Israel’s ancient rights to the land. A bit of an important passage, if you’re into that sort of thing.

22

The Command to Sacrifice Isaac

E source. Upon first reading, very disturbing. But, once I read the footnotes I am reminded again of the gulf between cultures, even between practiced and perceived religions. Traditionally, the first son ‘belongs to god.’ Thus, Isaac is the Lord’s to take. Abraham knows this as surely as any Montanan knows it is their right to carry a gun. I cannot judge Abraham’s actions, which turn out to his (and his sons) benefit without fully comprehending the zeitgeist, if you will. A lesson in modesty. Also of note, the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, where Abraham says “On the mount of the Lord it shall be provided.” Moving words, and once again they show the deep connection his people feel, and will feel for generations, to the land.

The Children of Nahor

J insert. Rebekah is a name I recognize, and I see she is coming up. I suppose this is just to provide some reference for family trees.

23

Not juicy. Relevant to followers as recognition of Holy (promised) Land, and astounding devotion to coverage of story from a literary standpoint. But, no murders. Yawn? Apparently, however, murders occur later according to Plotz. This becomes another contended site of Arabs and Jews, as if we needed another. How much pain and suffering can one text cause, even when it is not explicitly asking for it?

24

Abraham does not want his son to marry a Canaanite. One of the first restrictions? Where does this come from? It is frustrating, to not be able to love another, as in The Slave, where the Jew resists his feelings for the girl, with one reason being she is a Gentile. What is the historical or religious reason? Preservation of lineage? Pride? Anyways, hey Rebekah, welcome to Genesis.

25

Interesting foreshadowing in the account of Rebekah and Isaac’s children, Jacob and Esau. I must confess I am so ignorant of the Bible to know little of what will come to pass, but with or without this knowledge the passage is engaging. “Isaac loved Esau, because he was fond of game; but Rebekah loved Jacob.” This seems to be the first description of each parents’ feelings for the kids, a further enticing literary tool. The reader asks why, and reads on to find out. Is the bible intentionally full of small cliff hangers? Could it’s authors know that even the most devout would eventually need a little nudge?

Oh Jacob and Esau. A typical story of meathead and aspiring genius? J story, by the way, and it is hinted that this continues in later J translation in the footnotes. Congruity at last…

Also, Plotz notes the Genesis was written 1,000 years after Abraham was supposed to have lived. Just an interesting tidbit I would like to remember.

26

Once more God says “I will make your offspring as numerous as the stars of heaven…” (if you do this). And now people still expect this, and now there isn’t enough room. Bad call. I do wonder, why the emphasis on the spreading of the seed? Anyways, Isaac is off to Gerar. This J version closely resembles the E story of Abraham. Is this a purposeful repetition or a disagreeance of generation? I feel the answer could solve life’s riddles… Ok. So most likely a mistranslation or miscommunication. This follows too closely, and the ground with the wells and Philistines is named again, the same name.

27

“My son.” “Here I am.” Sounds familiar…just can’t quite place it. Oh right, sacrificial scene, how could I forget, no wonder those words are burned into Isaac’s memory. Once again, Jacob and Rebekah are conniving for Jacob’s success. Is this really the moral book I think it is? Is moral whatever God ordains, separate from human reason or intuition? Now his will is done, Jacob is master over his older brother, and perhaps this is the beginning of yet another feud.

Plotz calls to attention the difference, once again, between Sunday School heroes and the truth of the characters. I wonder, do the Sunday School teachers see something bright and shiny in these characters I do not, or do they choose not to see something. Are they trying to justify or make positive role models, hoping the children will never actually read the stories? I have little (NO) experience with bible school or true characters of the bible (working on it) but this just seems wrong. I protest.

Plotz also writes “God doesn’t suffer fools.” This is why he is allowed to be bamboozled. Huh. I have never seen intelligence to be too high up on the list for most….erm….everyday Christians. This must be some differing interpretation between the Jewish and the Christian ideals. Plotz mentions another difference between Christian and Jewish faiths, that of personal interest of God in everymans life. Makes one wonder just how much religion is based on a scripture, and how much based on a feeling.

28

P account of what just happened in the J story. This is much cleaner. It turns out Esau had already gave up his right to a blessing by marrying a Hittite woman, and so Jacob receives the blessing. He leaves to find a righteous wife, and on his way finds God. Of course. More endless loin-seeds sprouting everywhere, more importantly the consecrating of Bethel.

Ok. So, progress is slow. I may stop reading all the footnotes, am feeling this is a bit excessive, not to mention time consuming. So, will try to stop, although this may be the only chance I get in my life to read them in their entirety. I guess I will ask Prof. Sexson on his thoughts. Also, this is a long blog. Maybe a bit shorter next time… Experimenting is the name of the game.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

This is it: Genesis 1.0 through 19.0

Here goes. So far, I have been reading the bible passages, then looking at “The Good Book” for Plotz’s notes on concurrent sections. This provides motivation to finish chapters, as I have some humor to look forward to once I do. We will see how long this works for me. Also, more notes on class discussions in the next blog, but for now its all me.

“And God saw that it was good.” Wow. Well put Bible. I wonder if things really can be this easy. And if God saw it as good, shouldn’t we? I am on the fence…This whole giving dominion over everything to men, and not giving rain until there was man to plow the fields sounds so offensive to me. Call me hippie, but I have been thinking lately that life on this planet is not here because of us, we are here as a result of it—being able to digest it, hear it, see it, marvel at its beauty. We are, though debatable, somewhat relatively adapted to being here, and that is not because we were set here, but because we were created from this world around us. This is, of course, speculation. And from a heliocentric world view, I cannot expect the bible to even perceive of life not always existing as it had. I don’t know the truth, but I feel people might live with a lot more respect if they weren’t told that the world was created for them as their dominion.

….But then again, maybe they wouldn’t.

“It is a story of paradise and why we are no longer in it.” Somber words for explaining the beginning of the world in the (J) story bible. On this, I am really much less (I’m sure soon to be more) confused about the whole dual story parts of the bible. It is really neat to see both translations and edition, each giving story and backround gives a very full picture that is pleasing to be a part of. This is such an intricate layered work of art that it is hard to believe even the editors and compilers intended for it to be read literally. But I wouldn’t say the contradictions and repetitions lessen the value or beauty of the bible; rather they serve to illustrate how many people related with Christianity in different ways. That is beautiful in itself. This is sort of explained in The Genesis of Genesis: “The editors were not embarrassed by the duplications of particular episodes…..but, rather, valued te preservation of different traditions.”

Good Book’s author Plotz suggests something I can agree with when he writes “You can call this ‘original sin,’ but maybe it’s just lax parenting.” He writes this in reference to God’s not following through in killing Adam and Eve when they eat the apple, thus not being a strict guardian and encouraging more strife. I feel this makes sense, and suggests (as the Bible does as well) that God is not as all knowing, or perhaps perfect as the bible writes. Perhaps the bible was written in our childhood, revering the father as all youngsters do their parents, believing he can do no wrong. As humanity progresses, we become more familiar with our spiritual father and see the wrongs he could have righted, the ways in which we can learn from him, rather than be taught by him. Make sense?

Ahhh Cain and Abel. What to say, to this day I struggle with this story, praising it only for it’s inspiring Steinbeck’s East of Eden, one of my favorite books. But the story itself is beyond my comprehension, it just confuses and irritates me. Poor Cain, poor Abel. Poor us.

“Man seems to have been made mortal, but will henceforth be conscience of his mortality.” SICK JOKE! What a pain….

Flood time, AHA. “He blotted out every living thing that was on the face of the ground…” Is it irony? Prediction of things to come? That makes the rest of the world pay for our inherent evilness, back on the dominion idea. Let’s play around and mess around. Fuck things up? And when God feels bad, he makes a covenant, the first covenant. A bald-faced religious explanation for a natural phenomenon. I could see this story in any Greek legend…

Little Greek Boy: Father, what is that colored bow in the sky?

Big Greek Man: Well, our gods once became mad at us because too many little boys didn’t go to bed when they were asked. Thus, they created a storm to raise the waters of the oceans, drowning all of creation except for two (or seven) of every animal. Afterwards, the gods realized they couldn’t be so harsh, and to promise that after every rain there would be no more flood, they created the rainbow. Now go to bed.

So, why does this blow my mind? Of course this is what much of religious texts are, explaining of phenomenon. But for some reason I thought, in my Western World View, that the bible was a tiny bit more sophisticated than that. I think I like it more knowing that it’s not.

After the first covenant, comes the second. This one was made with Abram…to be father of multitudes, leader of Hebrews……all you have to do is cut your penis!

J version: “And he said, Oh yes, you did laugh.” Wow. Comedic relief. The two versions are interesting though, in how they differ like retelling an old family story, but the one part remains the same. In both versions Abraham or Sarah laugh that they will have children in their old age. Humor is universal?

Judgement on Sodom:

“Let me speak just once more” the narrowing down from fifty to ten innocent men. This is a great part, somehow beautiful I can’t put my finger on it. Maybe the courage with which Abraham confronts his Lord, or how the Lord hears him and considers. Slightly comical, almost as if the Lord is expecting it, or wishing for it. Again like a child/father relationship---going hunting, The Road, ect. Needing reassurance (both parties) and then “returning to his place”

All in all, a very inspiring first look at the bible.

Ethnographic means what?

Story of Babel interesting.

Ishmael—crazy---arab

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

A Day For Blogging Has Come

Here I sit, laptop in lap, setting out on a journey of blogging. I am now one of the many, the proud, the shameless self-promoters. While my ego is excited for the publicity, fame and attention my blog is sure to recieve (from my Mom, assuming she can figure out how to view it), I am also happy for an excuse to be forced to write, and to write at least a little more publicly than in a journal. Perhaps this will keep my typos to a minimum and my commentary to a maximum.

So here's to Bible reading, Prof. Sexson, endless thoughts and good times. Good luck class, good luck web.

-Shelby Rogala